In his final column as Dean of the Faculty of Dental Surgery and Vice President (Dental), Grant McIntyre wrote about time, how quickly it passes, and that being Dean of our Faculty has been an honour. I share this feeling of being truly humbled by becoming Dean and the responsibility that goes with the role. Grant is a great friend and mentor who has given so much to our College and achieved a great deal during his time as our Dean. He is an incredibly hard act to follow and I am glad he will still be on hand so I can ask for his advice.
Leadership is one of the most important factors influencing the success, sustainability and development of any institution. Whether in educational establishments, healthcare organisations, government departments, corporate organisations or non-profit institutions, effective leadership provides direction, establishes organisational culture and inspires individuals to work towards shared objectives. However, leadership is not permanent. Over time, institutions experience changes in leadership due to retirement, resignation, restructuring, succession planning, organisational challenges or the need for a fresh vision. As we have seen this week, even James Bond changes! A new 007 always seems to divide opinion – I wish Robert Pattinson every success in his new role but am not expecting any reciprocal good luck messages!
A change in leadership is more than simply replacing one individual with another. It represents an important period of transition that can influence an institution's values, priorities, policies, performance and future direction. When managed effectively, leadership change can introduce new ideas, strengthen institutional governance, encourage innovation and create opportunities for growth. Conversely, poorly managed transitions can result in uncertainty, resistance, declining morale and disruption to institutional operations.
It is not just a new James Bond that polarises opinions. Whilst changes in companies and institutions, such as a new CEO being appointed, are significant for employees, arguably changes in political leadership affect populations the most. I try and avoid political conversations as much as possible – I will leave it to you as readers to make your own minds up as to the quality of current world leaders. Different times require different values; for what it is worth, looking back at history, I recognise the strength of Winston Churchill in battling against what appeared to be insurmountable odds during the dark days of his tenure, and the humility, humanity and willingness to forgive of Nelson Mandela when he came to power, refusing to take revenge on those who had treated him so appallingly. Different circumstances needed distinctive leadership characteristics.
College colleagues and employees will have some apprehension as to what the future holds with a new Dean. Having been Vice Dean (UK) and served on Dental Council for five years, plus examining for the College for over twenty years, I know many of the College team and understand the challenges they face. I am cautious about any form of ideology that cannot recognise it’s own limitations. History shows that in most situations, evolution is better than revolution, adaptability more successful than immovability. However, one non-negotiable should be that, as a College, we put the highest standards and all that we do as our number one target.
In today's rapidly evolving world, change is inevitable; the ability to manage such transitions effectively is therefore essential to maintaining stability while striving to progress. Resourcing healthcare is currently not a top priority for governments and as a College, we must be resolute in finding ways to maintain and raise standards of dental health, both in the UK and internationally. Many of my friends and colleagues are based overseas and look to us to help them improve through our assessments and qualifications – we must ensure that our Diplomas, Memberships and Fellowships are still recognised as the ‘Gold standard’ that the dental profession aspires to.
So, I aim that the transition from Grant’s tenure as Dean will be as smooth as possible; the majority of Dental Council have been in place for some time and we have a very experienced Dental Executive who I will seek advice from on a regular basis. I will encourage everyone to contribute ideas, participate in decision-making and take greater responsibility for our development. However, colleagues understandably look for leadership and ensuring that dentistry is represented in the higher echelons of the College. One of my aims has always been and still is, to empower colleagues, creating opportunities for individuals to achieve beyond their previous perceived limitations, within an environment without ‘glass ceilings’. Being pushed from behind means we all have to continually improve to avoid being overtaken – these are challenges I enjoy.
As Dean, I bring personal experiences from primary and secondary care, university, regulatory and healthcare management positions. These different involvements have influenced how I believe decisions should be made, how resources allocated and how institutional challenges addressed. As I get older, I recognise how decisions taken now will influence the world our children (and in my case grandchildren) will live in. We have the responsibility and opportunity to drive our institutional priorities and strengthen organisational effectiveness – we must be bold and committed against negative opposition, both from within and outside.
As society evolves, we must adapt to new expectations and challenges. Digital transformation, technological advancement, changing educational requirements, financial pressures and increasing demands for transparency require leaders to have vision and expertise to drive necessary change and institutional culture. This culture refers to the shared values, beliefs, attitudes, traditions and practices that shape how people behave and interact. I am very fortunate to be taking over as Dean, when our College is still recognised as being supportive, friendly and welcoming to our new Members and Fellows. However, I do not take this position we hold as the oldest and best Surgical College in the world for granted; we can respect our institutional traditions whilst at the same time identifying areas for improvement and promoting improved dental health globally.
How do we do this? I believe the time has come for greater dialogue between key stakeholders in dentistry. In the UK this means our regulator, the General Dental Council, Dental Schools Council, COPDEND, BDA, indemnity societies and the Royal Colleges. The ‘blame culture’ must end and an era of clear integrated decision-making and responsibility taking has to start. Internationally, we as a College need to discuss with overseas colleagues how we can work together for mutual benefit. Indeed only last week when in Kuala Lumpur examining, I and Toby Gillgrass, Dental Vice Dean (International), had a very productive meeting with the board of the Malaysian Dental Association, discussing how we can work together to support dental colleagues in that region.
So what does the future hold? When experienced leaders leave, valuable knowledge, professional relationships and historical understanding can easily be lost. I am thrilled that Grant has agreed to continue within the College supporting our Heritage committee. This continuity will not only be a massive help to me personally but ensures that his expertise remains within the College.
My vision and priorities are to support all members of the dental team, not just the few. Dental care is increasingly delivered by teams as opposed to individuals and we must appeal to all dental registrants. I want us to be adaptable, innovative, decisive and transparent, communicating openly and honestly internally, with institutional partners and other relevant stakeholders; maintaining the current dialogue we have with our colleagues in the GDC and helping them with their challenges is a priority, which will benefit the whole profession. Listening is so important; our exam and education teams possess valuable operational knowledge that can help identify problems and opportunities that may not be immediately visible to senior management - I want to understand their experiences, concerns and suggestions, finding the right balance between continuity and innovation.
Our history, established values and previous achievements are our USP. These foundations should not be disregarded but we cannot remain stagnant. New challenges require fresh thinking, improved processes and a dynamic mentality. Innovation does not mean rejecting the past. Instead, it involves building upon existing strengths to create a better future, strengthening external partnerships and promoting a more inclusive decision-making environment.
Ultimately, the Dental Faculty and College are greater than any individuals who lead them. Deans will come and go, but our mission, values and commitment to excellence must remain. When leadership change is approached with wisdom, integrity and strategic foresight, it becomes more than a transfer of authority. It becomes an opportunity to build a stronger, more resilient and forward-looking institution for generations to come. I have only one thing in common with Robert Pattinson – I as Dental Dean and he as 007 – we both have an incredible honour to hold the roles we are now in, both for a brief tenure. Others will judge how successful we are – we both have hard acts to follow.