We use cookies to track usage and optimise user experience. By continuing to browse and use the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

RCSEd Response To Claims That 'Surgical Students Are Losing Dexterity To Stitch Patients'


« View all News items
01 Nov 2018

Are Aspiring Surgeons Losing their Dexterity Skills In the Digital Age?

World’s largest and oldest surgical college disagrees, with evidence gathered through its national undergraduate surgical skills competition and surgical skills courses

The BBC recently reported that medical students are ‘losing the dexterity to stitch patients’. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh (RCSEd) has observed contrary evidence to this, through its wide-range of surgical skills engagement activities, in particular its national Student Surgical Skills Competition, taken at undergraduate level to showcase and enhance surgical skills of the next the generation of surgeons.

RCSEd President, Professor Michael Lavelle-Jones a previous winner of the Association of Surgeons in Training (ASiT) Silver Scalpel Award which recognises excellence in surgical trainers, said:

“One of the main reasons our College launched the UK-wide National Surgical Skills Competition, was to provide opportunities for today’s medical students to get access to surgical skills training.   

“Possessing hands-on surgical skills is a key element for any aspiring undergraduate surgeon or indeed any surgeon in training. Our surgical competitions and our surgical skills workshops are challenging and rewarding events, which allow medical students to demonstrate their surgical capacities and practice their skills in an environment far closer to reality than any computer screen or textbook.

“This is now our fourth year running the competition, testing various surgical techniques - from suturing to laparoscopy - and it has certainly been evidential to us that participants who score highly with our dexterity challenges and our laparoscopic tests, are quite often those who in their pastimes enjoy computer games!”

Adding to this, Oxford-based consultant surgeon and Deputy Surgical Director of the RCSEd Advisory Network Mr Michael Silva said:

“RCSEd has been running nationwide surgical skills symposia and some excellent surgical skills workshops across the UK for undergraduates and surgical trainees for a number of years. From the events we have hosted and witnessed, we have been astonished at some of the superb dexterity skills showcased by today’s students and trainees.

“We are committed to nurturing and developing this talent and inspiring the next generation to pursuing a surgical career. The style of learning and techniques used to develop surgical skills today may be different from when I was in medical school or undergoing surgical training. There is emerging data in publications indicating that computer gaming experience enhances dexterity particularly laparoscopic skills.

“As surgery advances, we are dedicated to evolve our teaching and to support the best surgical training opportunities to the benefit of our profession. By improving surgical skills, we will ultimately produce better surgeons and achieve better surgical outcomes.”

Only 8% of all medical undergraduate students will eventually qualify as surgeons in one of the ten surgical specialties. Surgery is an incredibly competitive area, so being able to demonstrate the commitment and practical skills to become a surgeon at this early stage puts students at a great advantage later in their career.

The College’s groundbreaking Surgical Skills Competition is currently underway, with 19 heats taking place across all home nations this autumn / winter. Heats are held at each UK medical school with the winner of each heat receiving an invite to the Grand Final in Edinburgh in spring 2019.

Competing in the competition gives rare experience and has boosted the confidence of many medical students across the UK.  Recent Oxford University Medical School heat winner, Audrey Davies said:

The Surgical Skills Competition was a great chance to practice skills under pressure and get one-to-one supervision from senior consultants. I feel lucky to have a place in the National Final, and I am looking forward to going to Edinburgh in March. I know that exposure to different surgical skills and affiliation with the RCSEd will be a great way to start thinking about a career in surgery, both through the practical experience and also through meeting and speaking to people who know the field inside-out.

Read more about the RSCEd Surgical Skills Competition here.  


back to top of page